Post by Iñakink on Jul 23, 2008 10:00:56 GMT -5
Here's my idea. It may sound a bit complicated at first but it's very simple.
I nominate three bands/artists for our Hall Of Fame. The next poster chooses one of the three and inducts them/him, and nominates another three. So it's basically like the "This or that" but with bands and three options instead of two.
We can nominate bands and people who have released at least an album under the name we include (we can have The Kinks, Dave Davies and Ringo Starr, but not The Ravens or Ian Gibbons), and of course we shouldn't nominate bands or people that have already been inducted, that would be silly! Every few posts I'll post the full list of artists that have been inducted, with the person who nominated and the person who inducted each. We can nominate an artist all the times we want until he gets inducted.
Here's the best part: When we have a big list (I think about 150 would be the right number) we'll choose two songs for every band (one will be chosen by the person who nominated and the other one by the person who inducted). I'll manage to get mp3 files for all the songs, I'll put them into two different CDs, and I'll send copies to everyone who has participated. I suggest that we can have a special inducted: number 151 should be Tom Gallagher.
You can't complain on any induction, if the Gert Jonnys are chosen it means there are at least two fans who consider they deserve to be there and they'll be part of our Hall Of Fame, and there's nothing you can do about it. Let's try to keep it a bit serious though.
And we can nominate obscure bands (it would be great to have some inducted), but please don't say three bands nobody but you has ever heard about in the same post.
If you have any idea to improve the game or you have any doubt please feel free to post about it.
To start, I nominate:
The Kinks / The Beatles / The Rolling Stones
I nominate three bands/artists for our Hall Of Fame. The next poster chooses one of the three and inducts them/him, and nominates another three. So it's basically like the "This or that" but with bands and three options instead of two.
We can nominate bands and people who have released at least an album under the name we include (we can have The Kinks, Dave Davies and Ringo Starr, but not The Ravens or Ian Gibbons), and of course we shouldn't nominate bands or people that have already been inducted, that would be silly! Every few posts I'll post the full list of artists that have been inducted, with the person who nominated and the person who inducted each. We can nominate an artist all the times we want until he gets inducted.
Here's the best part: When we have a big list (I think about 150 would be the right number) we'll choose two songs for every band (one will be chosen by the person who nominated and the other one by the person who inducted). I'll manage to get mp3 files for all the songs, I'll put them into two different CDs, and I'll send copies to everyone who has participated. I suggest that we can have a special inducted: number 151 should be Tom Gallagher.
You can't complain on any induction, if the Gert Jonnys are chosen it means there are at least two fans who consider they deserve to be there and they'll be part of our Hall Of Fame, and there's nothing you can do about it. Let's try to keep it a bit serious though.
And we can nominate obscure bands (it would be great to have some inducted), but please don't say three bands nobody but you has ever heard about in the same post.
If you have any idea to improve the game or you have any doubt please feel free to post about it.
To start, I nominate:
The Kinks / The Beatles / The Rolling Stones